Justia Federal District Court Opinions

Citation	Date	Circuit	Parties
143 F.3d 1	Apr 27, 1998	First	In Re: I Don't Trust, Debtor.robert M. Prebor, Appellant, v. Joseph B. Collins, Trustee, et al., Appellees
143 F.3d 5	May 01, 1998	First	Merchants Insurance Company of New Hampshire, Inc.,plaintiff--appellee, v. United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co., Defendant--appellant
143 F.3d 11	May 04, 1998	First	United States of America, Appellee, v. James P. Florence, Defendant, Appellant
143 F.3d 18	May 05, 1998	First	United States of America, Appellant, v. Arnold I. Friedman, Defendant, Appellee
143 F.3d 24	Apr 01, 1998	Second	Patricia Chew, Individually and As Administratrix of Theestate of Daren Chew, Deceased and William Chew,plaintiffs-appellants, v. Bent Dietrich, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 31	Apr 28, 1998	Second	Mervyn Thomas, Minority Livery Owners and Drivers Coalition,neville Cooper, and Hispanic Coalition of Baseowners, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. City of New York, Diane Mcgrath-mckechnie, As Commissionerof the Taxi and Limousine Commission of the City of Newyork, Taxi and Limousine Commission of the City of New York,and New York City Council, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 38	Apr 28, 1998	Second	Ncas Realty Management Corp., Plaintiff-appellee, v. the National Corporation for Housing Partnerships and Thenational Housing Partnership, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 47	Apr 30, 1998	Second	Danny T. Greenway, Plaintiff-appellee Cross-appellant, v. the Buffalo Hilton Hotel, Defendant-appellant Cross-appellee
143 F.3d 56	Apr 30, 1998	Second	Dilipbhai Nathubhai Patel, Petitioner, v. Edward Mcelroy, District Director of the Immigration Andnaturalization Service of New York, and Janetreno, Attorney General of the Unitedstates, Respondents
143 F.3d 61	Apr 30, 1998	Second	Kevin Adams and Jay Williams, on Behalf of Themselves Andall Other Employees Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Department of Juvenile Justice of the City of New York Andthe City of New York, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 71	May 01, 1998	Second	22 Employee Benefits Cas. 1208,pens. Plan Guide (cch) P 23942yrobert D. Krumme, Plaintiff-appellee,gordon E. Allen; John Currier; Nicholas Pallotta; Jamesj. Dunne; Leo Fornero; Gerard P. Mandry; Normank. Matheson; Cochran P. Supplee Andbruce E. Moore, Plaintiffs-appellees,cross-appellants, v. Westpoint Stevens Inc., Formerly Known As Westpoint-pepperell, Inc., Defendant-appellant-cross-appellee,c. Powers Dorsett and D. Michael Roark, Defendants-cross-appellees
143 F.3d 88	May 04, 1998	Second	L & B 57th Street, Inc.,plaintiff-counter-defendant-appellant-cross-appellee, v. E.m. Blanchard, Inc. and Robert Blanchard,defendants-counter-claimants-appellees-cross-appellants
143 F.3d 94	May 04, 1998	Second	Michael Morales, Petitioner-appellant, v. United States of America, Respondent-appellee
143 F.3d 98	May 05, 1998	Second	Woodrow Williams, Petitioner-appellant, v. Brion Travis, Chairman, New York State Division of Parole;dennis C. Vacco, Attorney General of New York,respondents-appellees
143 F.3d 100	May 05, 1998	Second	James Atkins, Plaintiff--appellant, v. New York City, the New York City Police Department, Justice,shield No. 10274, P.o. Tudor, Shield No. Unknown, Sergeantbetterly, Shield No. Unknown, Detective Williams, Shield No.unknown, Individually, and in Their Official Capacities Aspolice Officers of the City of New York, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 105	May 05, 1998	Second	John Scotto, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Arcadio Almenas, Carol Forman, Kenneth Wegman, Barbara Mei,james F. O'rorke, Jr., Individually and As a Member of Thelaw Firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, New Yorkstate Division of Parole, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher &flom, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 115	May 05, 1998	Second	Maxine Clark, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 119	Jun 04, 1998	Second	State of New York, New York State Department of Socialservices, and the New York State Department Ofhealth, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Donna E. Shalala, As Secretary of the United Statesdepartment of Health and Human Services, Shirley S. Chater,as Commissioner of the United States Social Securityadministration, Franklin D. Raines, As Director of Theoffice of Management and Budget, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 120	Apr 29, 1998	Third	21 Employee Benefits Cas. 1073,pens. Plan Guide (cch) P 23942hfrank C. Schoonejongen; Wesley L. Losson; John S. Dunning;william Martone; William v. Hanzalek; Edward F. Ziek;melvin Deblock; Joseph Colquhoun; Joseph Majerscak;gerard Abbamont; and Olga Wolsey, on Behalf of Themselvesand All Others Similarly Situated, Appellants, v. Curtiss-wright Corporation
143 F.3d 133	Apr 29, 1998	Third	United States of America v. Juan Faulks, Appellant
143 F.3d 139	Apr 30, 1998		United States Court of Appeals,third Circuit
143 F.3d 157	May 01, 1998	Third	Aravinthan Balasubramanrim, Petitioner, v. Immigration and Naturalization Service, Respondent
143 F.3d 165	May 01, 1998	Fourth	Mt. Lookout--mt. Nebo Property Protection Association, Anunincorporated Association, Petitioner, v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Respondent,city of Summersville, West Virginia, Intervenor.american Whitewater Affiliation, Petitioner, v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Respondent,city of Summersville, West Virginia, Intervenor.mt. Lookout--mt. Nebo Property Protection Association, Anunincorporated Association, Petitioner, v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Respondent
143 F.3d 174	Jun 03, 1998	Fifth	Bankr. L. Rep. P 77,706, 12 Tex.bankr.ct.rep. 302united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Elwood Cluck, Also Known As Jack Cluck, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 181	Jun 03, 1998	Fifth	National Labor Relations Board, Petitioner, v. Thermon Heat Tracing Services, Inc., Respondent
143 F.3d 192	Jun 05, 1998	Fifth	Guaranty National Insurance Company and Landmark Americaninsurance Company, Plaintiffs-counter Defendants-appellees, v. Vic Manufacturing Company, Defendant-counter Claimant-appellant
143 F.3d 196	Jun 08, 1998	Fifth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Homero Valdez-valdez, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 203	Jun 08, 1998	Fifth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Massood Danesh Pajooh, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 205	Jun 18, 1998	Fifth	Maguire Oil Company, et al., Plaintiffs,maguire Oil Company, Plaintiff-appellee, v. the City of Houston, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 213	Jun 19, 1998	Fifth	Six Flags over Texas, Inc., Plaintiff-counter Defendant-appellee, v. International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local No.116, (affiliated with the Afl-cio), Individuallyand on Behalf of Bobby H. Honea,defendant-counter Claimant-appellant
143 F.3d 216	Jun 22, 1998	Fifth	Marinechance Shipping, Ltd., Plaintiff-appellee, v. Fernando Sebastian; Raul Galedo, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 223	Jun 22, 1998	Fifth	Bankr. L. Rep. P 77,721, 12 Tex.bankr.ct.rep. 287in the Matter Of: Sim Michael Gamble, Debtor.sim Michael Gamble, Appellant, v. Arcina Ann Gamble, Appellee
143 F.3d 227	Jun 22, 1998	Fifth	77 Fair Empl.prac.cas. (bna) 417,73 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 45,368monica M. Garcia, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Woman's Hospital of Texas, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 232	Jun 23, 1998	Fifth	Kenneth White, Plaintiff-appellee, v. United States of America, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 239	Jun 24, 1998	Fifth	Lubbock County Hospital District, Doing Business Asuniversity Medical Center, Plaintiff-appellee, v. National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa;aig Aviation Insurance Services; Caledonianinsurance Group, Inc., Defendants,national Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa;aig Aviation Insurance Services, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 246	Apr 17, 1998	Sixth	Everett Hadix, et al. (96-2567/2568); Mary Glover, et al.(96-2586/2588; 97-1218/1272),plaintiffs-appellees/cross-appellants, v. Perry M. Johnson, Director, et al.,defendants-appellants/cross-appellees
143 F.3d 260	May 01, 1998	Sixth	Fed. Sec. L. Rep. P 90,199, 22 Employee Benefitscas. 1001,pens. Plan Guide (cch) P 23942vsecurities and Exchange Commission, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Robert Johnston and Fiduciary Planning, Incorporated,defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 263	May 07, 1998	Sixth	Fed. Sec. L. Rep. P 90,201robert E. Rubin and Patricia Cohen, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn, Richard A. Barnhart, Danny L.todd, and Gregory A. Todd, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 274	Apr 17, 1998	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Joseph C. Minneman and Clarence G. Punke, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 286	Apr 23, 1998	Seventh	Ramon Ibarra, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Nancy Martin, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 293	Apr 23, 1998	Seventh	Lorenzo Brandon, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Chicago Board of Education, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 296	Apr 28, 1998	Seventh	Joseph Pisciotti, Petitioner-appellant, v. Odie Washington, Respondent-appellee
143 F.3d 302	Apr 28, 1998	Seventh	Warren K. Huntzinger and Nancy J. Huntzinger, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Hastings Mutual Insurance Company, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 317	Apr 29, 1998	Seventh	Lovilia Coal Company and Bituminous Casualty Corporation, Petitioners, v. Verda M. Williams and Office of Workers' Compensationprograms, Respondents
143 F.3d 325	Apr 30, 1998	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Clinton Elbert Mckinney, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 331	May 01, 1998	Seventh	73 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 45,352, 49 Fed. R. Evid.ser v. 330charles Collins, Plaintiff-appellee, v. D.j. Kibort and Educational Therapy Center, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 340	May 01, 1998	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Salvatore Carlino, Also Known As Sam Carlino, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 345	May 04, 1998	Seventh	Fabio A. Diaz, Petitioner-appellant, v. Jack R. Duckworth, Respondent-appellee
143 F.3d 348	May 04, 1998	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Robert A. Grossi, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 351	May 04, 1998	Seventh	Charles R. Strasburger, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Board of Education, Hardin County Community Unit Schooldistrict No. 1, Hardin County Education Association of Theillinois Education Association/national Educationassociation, Dan Austin, Dennis Austin, Dan Bridges, Andgerald Miller, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 362	May 05, 1998	Seventh	Barkat U. Khan and Khan & Associates, Inc., Plaintiffs-appellants, v. State Oil Company, Defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 364	May 05, 1998	Seventh	Bernard Podolsky, D/b/a Podolsky Oil Company, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Alma Energy Corporation and Equinox Oil Corporation,incorporated, Defendants-appellees.alma Energy Corporation, Equinox Oil Corporation,incorporated, M. Michael Galesi, and Stephen D.layton, Cross-appellants, v. Bernard Podolsky, D/b/a Podolsky Oil Company, and Michaelpodolsky, Cross-appellees
143 F.3d 373	May 06, 1998	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Robert E. Nelson, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 375	Apr 23, 1998	Eighth	United States of America, Appellee, v. Albion Norman, Appellant
143 F.3d 379	Apr 23, 1998	Eighth	United States of America, Appellee, v. Lord Kang, Appellant
143 F.3d 383	Apr 23, 1998	Eighth	56 Soc.sec.rep.ser. 462, Unempl.ins.rep. (cch) P 16010bphyllis Y. Black, Appellant, v. Kenneth S. Apfel, Commissioner, Social Securityadministration, Appellee
143 F.3d 387	Apr 24, 1998	Eighth	Gs Roofing Products Company; Beazer West, Doing Business Asgifford-hill & Company, Inc.; Bean Lumbercompany; Curt Bean Lumber Company, Petitioners, v. Surface Transportation Board, Respondent,united States of America, Respondents,arkansas Midland Railroad Company, Inc., Intervenor on Appeal
143 F.3d 397	Apr 29, 1998	Eighth	United States of America, Appellee, v. Jonathan S. Gilbert, Appellant
143 F.3d 399	Apr 30, 1998	Eighth	United States of America, Appellee, v. Mambu Fulgham, Appellant
143 F.3d 402	Apr 30, 1998	Eighth	76 Fair Empl.prac.cas. (bna) 1244,73 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 45,350mark A. Stolzenburg, Appellant/cross-appellee, v. Ford Motor Company, Appellee/cross-appellant
143 F.3d 408	May 01, 1998	Eighth	United States of America, Appellee, v. John Raymond Koontz, Appellant
143 F.3d 414	May 01, 1998	Eighth	Forrest E. Mueller, Appellant, v. Guardian Life Insurance Company, a Corporation; Guardianlife Insurance Company of America, a Corporation; Austinschussler, Regional Director of Agencies for the Guardianlife Insurance Company, Appellees
143 F.3d 417	May 01, 1998	Eighth	Clovis Jones, Appellee, v. Conway County, Arkansas, and Morrilton Housing Authority, Defendants,conway County Election Commission; Jean Hervey, in Herofficial Capacity As a Conway County Election Commissioner;randall Wolfe, in His Official Capacity As a Conway Countyelection Commissioner; and Robert Carruthers, in Hisofficial Capacity As a Conway County Election Commissioner, Appellants,city of Morrilton, Arkansas, Defendant
143 F.3d 419	May 01, 1998	Eighth	21 Employee Benefits Cas. 1065,pens. Plan Guide (cch) P 23942salexis M. Herman, Secretary of the United States Departmentof Labor, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Mercantile Bank, N.a., Defendant-appellee,lenco, Inc., Employees' Stock Ownership Plan & Trust,defendant-appellee
143 F.3d 428	May 04, 1998	Eighth	Telectronics Pacing Systems, Inc.; Telectronics Holding,ltd.; Telectronics Pty., Ltd.; Medical Telectronicsholding and Finance Co., (bv); Telectronics, Nv; Tplc,inc.; Telectronics, Sa; Pacesetter, Inc., Appellants/cross-appellees, v. Guidant Corporation; Cardiac Pacemakers, Inc.; Guidantsales Corp.; Eli Lilly and Co., Appellees/cross-appellants
143 F.3d 434	May 04, 1998	Eighth	Linda Schiernbeck, Appellant, v. Clark Davis and Rosa Davis, Appellees
143 F.3d 441	May 04, 1998	Eighth	James E. Rodden, Appellant, v. Paul Delo; William Webster, Appellees
143 F.3d 449	May 05, 1998	Eighth	Bryan Kirby Barrett, Appellee/cross-appellant, v. Gerardo Acevedo, Appellant/cross-appellee
143 F.3d 466	May 05, 1998	Eighth	Steve Leonard, Lavonda Leonard, Appellants, v. Christopher Walthall, Appellee
143 F.3d 469	May 06, 1998	Eighth	Richard Ray Layton; Billy R. Penny, Appellants, v. Ted Elder, As County Judge of Montgomery County, Arkansas, Appellee
143 F.3d 473	Aug 13, 1997	Ninth	Oona, R.-s.-, a Minor, by Kate S., Her Guardian, Kate S. Andken R., Plaintiff-appellee, v. Patricia Mccaffrey; Gerald Hill; Ronald Lundy,defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 479	Jan 20, 1998	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3189, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 10,111,98 Daily Journal D.a.r. 4399united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Michael Curtis Keys, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 480	Apr 24, 1998	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3091, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 4265united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Jose Arturo Sanchez-anaya, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 481	Apr 24, 1998	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3080, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 4251confederated Tribes of Siletz Indians of Oregon, Plaintiff-appellee, v. State of Oregon; Oregon State Police Department; R.j.sitton, Lieutenant, Oregon State Police Tribalgaming Unit, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 487	Apr 29, 1998	Ninth	Donald J. Peracchi; Judith E. Peracchi, Petitioners-appellants, v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent-appellee
143 F.3d 497	Apr 29, 1998	Ninth	James O. Henderson, Petitioner-appellant, v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent-appellee
143 F.3d 502	Apr 29, 1998	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3185, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 4396reliance Insurance Co., a Pennsylvania Corporation, Plaintiff-appellee, v. U.S. Bank of Washington, N.a., a National Bankingassociation, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 508	Dec 18, 1997	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3248, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 4527giancarlo Parretti, Petitioner-appellant, v. United States of America, Respondent-appellee
143 F.3d 513	May 01, 1998	Ninth	Fereshteh Abbassi, Petitioner, v. Immigration and Naturalization Service, Respondent
143 F.3d 515	May 04, 1998	Ninth	Southwest Center for Biological Diversity, a Non-profitcorporation, Plaintiff-appellant,arizona Power Authority; Metropolitan Water District Ofsouthern California; Southern Nevada Water Authority; Saltriver Valley Water Users Association; Salt River Projectagricultural Improvement and Power District, Intervenors-appellees,andstate of Arizona; Rita P. Pearson; State of Colorado;state of New Mexico; State of Utah; State Ofwyoming; State of Nevada; Defenders Ofwildlife, by Special Appearance, v. U.S. Bureau of Reclamation; Bruce Babbitt, Secretary of Theinterior, Defendants-appellees.southwest Center for Biological Diversity, a Non-profitcorporation, Plaintiff-appellee,state of Arizona; State of Colorado; State of New Mexico;state of Utah; State of Wyoming; State Ofnevada, Appellants by Special Appearance,andarizona Power Authority; Rita P. Pearson; Metropolitanwater District of Southern California; Defenders Ofwildlife; Southern Nevada Water Authority; Salt Rivervalley Water Users Association; Salt River Projec
143 F.3d 524	May 04, 1998	Ninth	State of Alaska Ex Rel. Yukon Flats School District,unalakleet/neeser Construction Jv, Unalakleetnative Corporation, Neeser Constructioncompany, and Gerald Neeser,plaintiffs-appellees, v. Native Village of Venetie Tribal Government, A/k/a Thenative Village of Venetie, the Venetie Tax Court, Thevenetie Tax Commission, Gideon James, Lawrence Roberts,larry Williams, Ernest Erick, Lincoln Tritt, John Titus, Anddavid Case, Defendants-appellants
143 F.3d 525	May 05, 1998	Ninth	Larry M. Siegel; Selwyn Gerber, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation; J.i. Kislakmortgage Corporation; Gunther Torriani; Carolynpaz, Defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 525	May 04, 1998	Ninth	L'anza Research International, Inc., Plaintiff-appellee, v. Quality King Distributors, Inc., a New York Corporation,defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 534	May 05, 1998	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3361, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 4667united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Jose Rosario Garibay, Jr., Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 540	May 06, 1998	Ninth	98 Cal. Daily Op. Ser v. 3400, 98 Daily Journald.a.r. 4711bruce Flanagan; Joan Flanagan, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Howard Arnaiz; Helen Rae Byrnes; Patricia A. Carson;clyde C. Cournale; Roy M. Guinnane; Sidneylewin; Smith Ketchum, Iii; Josephmoore; Shirley Talbot,defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 546	May 06, 1998	Ninth	In Re Ceresa Annette Rothery, Debtor.larry Cunningham, Appellant, v. Ceresa Rothery, Appellee
143 F.3d 550	Apr 20, 1998	Tenth	Heartsprings, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant, v. Heartspring, Inc., A.k.a. Institute of Logopedics, Inc.,defendant--appellee
143 F.3d 565	Apr 30, 1998	Tenth	In Re Special Grand Jury 89-2
143 F.3d 573	May 01, 1998	Tenth	Harry H. Mcwilliams, Ii, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Logicon, Inc., a Delaware Corporation; Logicon Technicalservices, Inc., a California Corporation,defendants-appellees
143 F.3d 577	May 01, 1998	Tenth	United States of America, Plaintiff--appellee, v. Priscilla J. Deters, Defendant--appellant
143 F.3d 585	May 01, 1998	Tenth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Johnny Blaze, A/k/a Ruben Hur Cedeno, A/k/a "carl",defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 595	May 01, 1998	Tenth	In Re James Berry Craddock, D/b/a Craddock Development Company, Debtor,united States of America, Internal Revenue Service, Claimant-appellant, v. James Berry Craddock, Debtor-appellee
143 F.3d 606	May 15, 1998	DC	Mci Telecommunications Corporation, et al., Petitioners, v. Federal Communications Commission and United States Ofamerica, Respondents,sprint Corporation, et al., Intervenors
143 F.3d 610	May 22, 1998	DC	Public Utilities Commission of the State of California, Petitioner, v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Respondent,mojave Pipeline Company, et al., Intervenors
143 F.3d 618	May 22, 1998	DC	Alan Gottlieb, et al., Appellants, v. Federal Election Commission, Appellee
143 F.3d 623	Mar 06, 1998	First	40 Collier Bankr.cas.2d 71, Bankr. L. Rep. P 77,699in Re James N. Papatones, Debtor.edward Elliott, et al., Appellees, v. James N. Papatones, Appellant
143 F.3d 626	May 13, 1998	First	Seacoast Motors of Salisbury, Inc., Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Chrysler Corporation, Defendant, Appellee
143 F.3d 629	Jun 01, 1998	First	James A. Chute, Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Sears Roebuck and Company and Emerson Electric Company,defendants, Appellees
143 F.3d 632	Apr 22, 1998	Second	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Juan R. Munoz, A/k/a John Doe # 1, Defendant-appellant
143 F.3d 638	Apr 23, 1998	Second	The Irish Lesbian and Gay Organization, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Rudolph W. Giuliani, in His Official Capacity As Mayor Ofthe City of New York; William J. Bratton, in His Officialcapacity As Police Commissioner of the City of New York;and City of New York, Defendants-appellees,new York County Board of the Ancient Order of Hibernians,defendant-intervenor-appellee