188 Cases, Displaying Page 1 of 1
Citation Date Circuit Parties
204 F.3d 1 Feb 17, 2000 First Luis A. Acevedo-garcia, et al., Plaintiffs, Appellees, v. Roberto Vera-monroig, et al., Defendants, Appellants
204 F.3d 14 Feb 17, 2000 First Pedro Oscar Cruz, et al., Plaintiffs, Appellants, v. Juan R. Melecio, Etc., et al., Defendants, Appellees
204 F.3d 25 Feb 22, 2000 First Arturo Rodriguez, Petitioner, v. Immigration and Naturalization Service, Respondent
204 F.3d 29 Dec 01, 1999 Second Pedro Nieblas, Petitioner-appellant, v. Carl A. Smith, Superintendent, Marcy Correctional Facility, Respondent-appellee
204 F.3d 33 Feb 17, 2000 Second James D. Wilson, Petitioner-appellant, v. Hans Walker, Superintendent, Auburn Correctional Facility, Respondent-appellee
204 F.3d 39 Feb 18, 2000 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Harry R. Carboni, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 48 Nov 08, 1999 Second Bernadette Williams, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Kenneth Apfel, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 50 Feb 16, 2000 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Ricaurte Saldarriaga, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 53 Feb 15, 2000 Third Nathaniel West, Appellant v. Donald Vaughn, Superintendent of Sci Graterford; the District Attorney of County of Phila.; the Attorney General of the State of Pa
204 F.3d 65 Feb 15, 2000 Third Douglas Nyhuis, Appellant v. Janet Reno, Attorney General; Eric Holder, Deputy Attorney General; Kathleen Hawk, Director-bop; John Hahn, Warden
204 F.3d 78 Feb 08, 2000 Third Warner-lambert Company, Appellant, v. Breathasure, Inc., on Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey Civil No.: 98-cv-01940 District Court Judge: Honorable John W. Bissell
204 F.3d 97 Jan 25, 2000 Third United States of America, v. Daniel Duliga, Appellant
204 F.3d 102 Sep 27, 1999 Third Alan T. Brooks, Appellant, v. Kyler, Superintendent; Porterfield, Sgt.; Rupinski, C.o.; All Defendants Are Being Sued in Their Official and Individual Capacity, C.o
204 F.3d 109 Nov 17, 1999 Third Dana Hedges; George Hedges, on Behalf of C.d. Minor, Appellants v. Ralph Musco, Individually and As Principal of Northern Highlands Regional High School; Greg Mcdonald; Cathy Kiely; Northern Highlands Regional High School Board of Education; Alan Geisenheimer, Individually and As President and a Member of the Northern Highlands Regional High School Board of Education; William Beisswanger, Individually and As President and a Member of the Northern Highlands Regional High School Board of Education; Mary Laurent; Barclay Blayman; Harold De Niear; Lynnette Krueger; Patricia Dubie; Linda Kempey; Nora Oliver; Tina Malizia; Neal Strohmeyer, Individually and As Members of the Northern Highlands Regional High Schoolboard of Education; Urgent Care-waldwick; Health Net Medical Group; Barbara Newman
204 F.3d 124 Feb 09, 2000 Fourth In Re: Genesys Data Technologies, Incorporated, Debtor.john Meindl; Genesys Data Technologies, Incorporated, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Genesys Pacific Technologies, Incorporated, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 133 Feb 14, 2000 Fourth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Troy Rolle, A/k/a Robert Stan Marks, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 141 Feb 22, 2000 Fourth Zeb Artis, Petitioner, v. Norfolk & Western Railway Company; Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, United States Department of Labor, Respondents.norfolk & Western Railway Company, Petitioner, v. Zeb Artis; Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, United States Department of Labor, Respondents
204 F.3d 149 Feb 23, 2000 Fourth Friends of the Earth, Incorporated; Citizens Local Environmental Action Network, Incorporated, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Gaston Copper Recycling Corporation, Defendant-appellee. United States of America, Amicu Curiae
204 F.3d 165 Feb 08, 2000 Fifth Joe Wallace, Doing Business As Video Liquidators, Plaintiff-appellant v. Michael E. Wellborn, et al., Defendantslisa Sheppard, Department of Public Safety Agent, Danny Contreras, Department of Public Safety Agent, Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 168 Feb 09, 2000 Fifth Leslie Parnell Felder Petitioner - Appellant v. Gary L Johnson, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Institutional Division Respondent - Appellee
204 F.3d 177 Feb 09, 2000 Fifth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. al Richards, Kurt Latrasse, and Roger Braugh, Defendants-appellants
204 F.3d 214 Feb 10, 2000 Fifth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Luis Obed Rios-quintero, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 220 Feb 10, 2000 Fifth Kimberle Mcgruder, Plaintiff - Cross-appellee,sharon Scott; Tonya Odionesene; Davis Enaohwo; Marlene Burgess; Maureen Adams, Also Known As Maureen Gonzalas; Laverne Crump, Also Known As Laverne Crump-smith; Marion Milburn; Consuela Haskins, Plaintiffs - Appellants-cross-appellees, v. Tom Will, Deputy Constable, in His Individual Capacity, Precinct 5; Martin Spears, Deputy Constable, in His Individual Capacity, Precinct 5; Glen Cheek, Constable, in His Individual and Official Capacities; James L. Douglas, Constable, in His Official Capacity, Precinct 3; Securiteestor Inc, Doing Business As Security Storage, Doing Business As King David Moving & Storage, Defendants - Appellees,marc Seymour, Defendant - Appellee-cross-appellant
204 F.3d 223 Feb 10, 2000 Fifth Tamara L. Hughes, Plaintiff-appellant, v. City of Garland, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 229 Feb 01, 2000 DC Animal Legal Defense Fund, Inc., et al.,appellees v. Daniel R. Glickman, in His Official Capacity As Secretary, United States Department of Agriculture, et al.,appellantsnational Association for Biomedical Research, Appellee
204 F.3d 236 Feb 22, 2000 DC United States of America, Appellee v. Davon M. Harrison, Appellant
204 F.3d 243 Feb 29, 2000 DC Herbert L. Schoenbohm, Appellant v. Federal Communications Commission, Appellee
204 F.3d 251 Mar 03, 2000 DC Susan M. Borgo, Appellee v. Daniel S. Goldin, Administrator, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Appellant
204 F.3d 259 Mar 07, 2000 DC Daniel S. Jacobs, Appellant v. Lois J. Schiffer, in Her Official Capacity As Assistant Attorney General for the Environment and Natural Resources Division of the U.S. Department of Justice, Appellee
204 F.3d 267 Mar 07, 2000 DC United States of America, Appellee v. Rachel L. Breedlove, Appellant
204 F.3d 275 Feb 25, 2000 First United States of America, Plaintiff, Appellee, v. Comunidades Unidas Contra La Contaminacion, Plaintiff-intervenor, Appellant, v. Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority, Defendant, Appellee
204 F.3d 283 Feb 25, 2000 First United States of America, Appellee, v. Eddy I. Sandoval, Defendant, Appellant
204 F.3d 287 Feb 25, 2000 First Wanda Negron-rivera, Plaintiff, Appellee, v. Angel L. Rivera-claudio, et al., Defendants, Appellees,maderas Tratadas, Inc., Defendant, Appellant
204 F.3d 291 Feb 29, 2000 First Carlos A. Romero, Jr., Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Colegio De Abogados De Puerto Rico and Harry Anduze, Defendants, Appellees
204 F.3d 306 Feb 29, 2000 First Stephen C. Fithian, Jr., P.p.a. Stephen C. Fithian, Sr., et al., Plaintiffs, Appellants, v. Edward Reed and Martha Reed, Defendants, Appellees
204 F.3d 311 Feb 23, 2000 Second Graeme Freeman, Mary Beth Freeman, Frank Ittleman, Elaine Ittleman, Mike Fournier, Holly Fournier, Ellen Lane, William Pinney, Jr., Mark W. Bolles, Claudia Mucklow, Donna A. Wark, Iris Muggenthaler, James H. Squires, Lawrencehamilton, Robert Carmody, Mark Musiel, Michael Yantachka, Lorie Gadboury, Chris Mcgee, Peter Coleman, Barbara Sanford Farrell, and William Pinney, Sr.,plaintiffs-appellants, v. Burlington Broadcasters, Inc., D/b/a Wizn, Charlotte Fire & Rescue Services, Inc., and Nynex Mobile Limited Partnership 1, D/b/a Bell Atlantic Nynex Mobile, Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 326 Feb 28, 2000 Second Douglas Parker, Plaintiff-appellant-cross-appellee, v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Defendant-appellee-cross-appellant,sony Pictures Entertainment, Inc., Defendant-appellee,sony Corporation of America, Defendant
204 F.3d 343 Feb 28, 2000 Second Debra Bassett, Doing Business As Bassett Productions, Bassett Entertainment Corp., Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Mashantucket Pequot Tribe, Mashantucket Pequot Museum & Research Center, Theresa Bell, Jack Campisi Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 360 Feb 28, 2000 Second Darius Morgan, Petitioner-appellant, v. Floyd Bennett, Superintendent, Elmira Correctional Facility, Respondent-appellee
204 F.3d 372 Feb 28, 2000 Second Howard T. Mowers, Plaintiff-appellee-cross-appellant, v. the Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., Also Known As Paul Revere Insurance Company, Defendant-appellant-cross-appellee
204 F.3d 376 Feb 28, 2000 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Pedro Nelson Rondon and Nelson Emmanuel Rondon-trinidad, Defendants-appellants
204 F.3d 381 Feb 14, 2000 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Grady Thomas, Ramse Thomas, and Jason Thomas, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 384 Feb 25, 2000 Second Transatlantic Shiffahrtskontor1 Gmbh, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Shanghai Foreign Trade Corporation, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 392 Jan 13, 2000 Second Joseph M. Pallozzi, Lori M. Pallozzi, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Allstate Life Ins. Co., Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 393 Feb 17, 2000 Second Julia Karen Eisemann Plaintiff-appellant, v. Miriam Greene, M.d., Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 397 Feb 17, 2000 Second James Lichtenberg, on Behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly Situated, John Bansbach, on Behalf of Himself and All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Besicorp Group Inc., Michael F. Zinn, Melanie Norden, Michael J. Daley, Gerald A. Habib, Richard E. Rosen, Steven I. Eisenberg, Defendants-appellants,bgi Acquisition Corp., Martin E. Enowitz, and Bgi Acquisition Llc, Defendants
204 F.3d 407 Feb 25, 2000 Second National Loan Investors L.p., Plaintiff-appellant-cross-appellee, v. Town of Orange; Arthur Williams, Defendants,water Pollution Control Authority, Defendant-appellee-cross-appellant
204 F.3d 413 Feb 25, 2000 Second State of Connecticut, Plaintiff-appellant, v. United States Department of Commerce, William M. Daley, Secretary, Defendant-appellee,state of New Jersey and State of Rhode Island, Department of Environmental Management, Movants
204 F.3d 417 Nov 01, 1999 Third Dale Swartz, Appellant v. Meyers, Superintendent; Pennsylvania Attorney General
204 F.3d 425 Jun 18, 1999 Third John Paff; James Timothy Konek, Individuals, Appellants v. George Kaltenbach, in His Individual and Official Capacities; John Does 1-3; the Township of East Brunswick
204 F.3d 442 Feb 29, 2000 Third Robert J. Harte, Appellant v. Bethlehem Steel Corporation; General Pension Board of the Bethlehem Steel Corporation and Subsidiary Companies; Michael P. Dopera, Secretary, Employee Benefits Administration Committee
204 F.3d 453 Feb 29, 2000 Third Edward R. Coss, Jr., Appellant v. Lachine County District Attorney; the Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
204 F.3d 453 Mar 21, 2000 Third Robert J. Harte, Appellant v. Bethlehem Steel Corporation; General Pension Board of the Bethlehem Steel Corporation and Subsidiary Companies; Michael P. Dopera, Secretary, Employee Benefits Administration Committee
204 F.3d 475 Mar 07, 2000 Third David L. Adams; Aaron F. Andrews; Paul A. Archibald; Lynn E. Aurand; Dorothy E. Baker; Charles Banshiere; John O. Bashore; Albert L. Basom; Vaughn K. Baumgardner; Ronald L. Beckwith; William K. Bell, Jr.; Charles E. Bender; Joseph G. Berrier; Edward W. Bickel; Clarence R. Boreman, Jr.; Harry Bradley, Jr.; John H. Clark; Joseph R. Close; John A. Clouser; Charles W. Condo; H. Ray Confer; Thomas J. Connare; Donald G. Cook; Ronald W. Crawford; Glen F. Crissman; Gerald W. Crisswell; Charles R. Cruikshank; William L. Cummings; Frank J. Davidheiser; William A. Davis; David S. Downing; Gerald G. Dumm; Richard H. Eaton; Paul E. Emmerling; Philip H. Erb; Gerald Erb; Roy J. Freed; Marvin E. Fultz; Clarence Galvin; Ralph A. Gaul, Jr.; Frank H. Geissinger; James T. Gilbert; Harvey W. Gilbert, Jr.; Robert W. Gilliland; Gene M. Hagenberger; Larry L. Harshbarger; James L. Harshbarger; Carl L. Hartsock; Edwin E. Heister; Joseph E. Heller; David S. Herst; T. Lewis Hetrick; William L. Hile; Donald Horner; John B. Hostetler; Mel
204 F.3d 494 Jan 24, 2000 Third Robert D. Shaner, Jr., Appellant v. Synthes (usa)
204 F.3d 508 Feb 11, 2000 Fourth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Corey Deon Goodson, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 516 Feb 25, 2000 Fourth In Re: Grand Jury Subpoenaunited States of America, Respondent-appellee, v. Under Seal, Petitioner-appellant
204 F.3d 523 Feb 25, 2000 Fourth United States Postal Service, Plaintiff-appellee, v. American Postal Workers Union, Afl-cio, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 536 Feb 25, 2000 Fourth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Olusola A. Alalade, A/k/a George Alalade, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 541 Feb 25, 2000 Fourth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Vinson Lamont Jones, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 544 Feb 28, 2000 Fourth Konstantinos Tasios, Petitioner-appellee, v. Janet Reno; Doris Meissner, Commissioner of the Immigration and Naturalization Service; Patrick J. Walters, As the Officer in Charge for the Charlotte Subdivision Office of the Immigration and Naturalization Service, Respondents-appellants
204 F.3d 553 Mar 02, 2000 Fourth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Clinton Bernard Frazier-el, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 580 Jan 21, 2000 Fifth Sierra Club; Wilderness Society; Texas Committee on Natural Resources Plaintiffs-appellees v. R Max Peterson, et Al, Defendants,daniel Glickman, in His Official Capacity As the Secretary of the Department of Agriculture; Gloria Manning, in Her Official Capacity As the Acting Regional Forester, U.S. Forest Service, Region 8; Michael Dombeck, in His Official Capacity As Chief, U.S. Forest Service; Ronald Raum, in His Official Capacity As the Forest Supervisor, National Forests and Grasslands in Texas Defendants-appellants,texas Forestry Association; Southern Timber Purchasers Council Intervenors-defendants-appellants
204 F.3d 581 Feb 10, 2000 Fifth United States of America Plaintiff-appellee v. Robert Randall Reinhart Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 581 Feb 16, 2000 Fifth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Jose Efrain Ceniceros, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 585 Feb 18, 2000 Fifth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Flora Alicia Ocana, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 595 Feb 18, 2000 Fifth In the Matter Of: Salomon Ramirez; Maria A. Ramirez, Debtors.salomon Ramirez; Maria A. Ramirez, Appellants, v. Phyllis Bracher, Chapter 13 Trustee, Appellee
204 F.3d 601 Feb 18, 2000 Fifth Denise Chavez,plaintiff-appellee, v. Arte Publico Press, et al., Defendants-appellants
204 F.3d 609 Feb 18, 2000 Fifth Mayola A. Henry, Surviving Spouse of Johnnie Henry and His Sole Legatee; Petitioner, v. Coordinated Caribbean Transport; American Motorists Insurance Company; and Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, United States Department of Labor; Respondents
204 F.3d 613 Mar 02, 2000 Fifth Edward Weekly, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Sharon M. Morrow, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 616 Mar 02, 2000 Fifth Ingalls Shipbuilding, Inc., Petitioner, v. James E. Wooley; Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, United States Department of Labor, Respondents
204 F.3d 619 Mar 02, 2000 Fifth Robert D. Allen, Plaintiff-appellant v. Rapides Parish School Board, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 624 Mar 02, 2000 Fifth Johnny Wade Howe, Individually and on Behalf of Courtney Howe, Plaintiff-intervenor Defendant-appellant v. Scottsdale Insurance Co.; et al., Defendants,louisiana State University Medical Center Intervenor Plaintiff-appellee
204 F.3d 629 Mar 03, 2000 Fifth Robert Lee Beck, Md, Dmd, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Texas State Board of Dental Examiners; et Al, Defendants,michael Pitcock; William S. Nail; William J. Kemp, Dr; Brian Babin, Dr; Jack L. Bolton, Dr; Randolph D Minatra, Dr; Frank Santos, Dr; Terry R. Dickinson, Dr; Roger Byrne, Dr; Charles T. Ku, Dr; Ronald H Shamblin, Dr, Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 639 Mar 06, 2000 Fifth Endrias Gebreyesus, Doing Business As Oda Trading Agency, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Fc Schaffer & Associates, Inc., Defendant-appelleeandmesfin Gebreyes; Kifle Gebre., Appellees.fc Schaffer & Associates Inc, Plaintiff-appelleeandmesfin Gebreyes; Kifle Gebre, Appellees v. Endrias Gebreyesus, Doing Business As Oda Trading Agency, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 645 Mar 08, 2000 Fifth Gilbert G. Ybanez Petitioner-appellant v. Gary L. Johnson, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Institutional Division Respondent-appelleerolland E. Lawson Petitioner-appellant v. Gary L. Johnson, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Institutional Division Respondent-appellee
204 F.3d 647 Mar 09, 2000 Fifth Black Sea Investment, Ltd., Plaintiff-counter Defendant-appellant, v. United Heritage Corporation, Defendant-counter Claimant-appellee
204 F.3d 652 Feb 24, 2000 Sixth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Joseph Kelly, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 658 United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Any and All Radio Station Transmission Equipment, Radio Frequency Power Amplifiers, Radio Frequency Test Equipment and Any Other Equipment Associated with or Used in Connection with the Transmission at 97.7 Mhz, Located at 2903 Bent Oak Highway, Adrian, Michigan, Defendant-appellee,rick Strawcutter, Claimant-appellee
204 F.3d 669 Feb 28, 2000 Sixth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Alton Ray Mills and Stephen D. Toarmina, Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 673 Feb 25, 2000 Sixth Marcia Fazekas; Carole Leland; Carol Pernell; Susan Shelko; Rebecca Winfield, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. the Cleveland Clinic Foundation Health Care Ventures, Inc., Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 680 Jul 29, 1999 Sixth Rudolph Jones, Jr.; Et. Al., Plaintiffs-appellants, v. City of Lakeland, Tennessee, a Tennessee Municipal Corporation, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 680 Oct 28, 1999 Sixth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Johnny E. Gatewood, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 681 Feb 25, 2000 Sixth Tyrone K. Harris, Petitioner-appellant, v. United States of America, Respondent-appellee
204 F.3d 683 Feb 25, 2000 Sixth Balance Dynamics Corporation, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Schmitt Industries, Incorporated, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 698 Jan 20, 2000 Sixth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. 150 Acres of Land, More or Less, Located in Medina County, Ohio,defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 713 Feb 17, 2000 Seventh Robert P. Beatty, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Phillip S. Wood and Wood & Johnson, P.c., Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 719 Feb 24, 2000 Seventh Empress Casino Joliet Corporation, Petitioner/cross-respondent, v. National Labor Relations Board, Respondent/cross-petitioner,andamerican Maritime Officers, Intervenor-respondent
204 F.3d 723 Feb 24, 2000 Seventh Brian E. Davis, Plaintiff-appellant, v. United States Department of Justice, et al., Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 727 Feb 24, 2000 Seventh Raymond D. Wright, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Illinois Department of Corrections, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 736 Feb 28, 2000 Seventh Central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Pension Fund and Howard Mcdougall, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Hunt Truck Lines, Inc., an Iowa Corporation, Defendant-appellee.central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Pension Fund and Howard Mcdougall, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Hunt Truck Lines, Inc., an Iowa Corporation, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 744 Oct 19, 1999 Seventh Bharat Bhatt, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Janet Reno, et al., Defendants-appellees
204 F.3d 748 Feb 08, 2000 Seventh Theresa L. Cannon Williams, on Behalf of Herself and All Others Similarly Situated, and Lois Reed, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Chartwell Financial Services, Ltd., Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 761 Feb 11, 2000 Seventh United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. John J. Montani, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 772 Feb 11, 2000 Seventh Dennis L. Hayden and Sharon E. Hayden, Petitioners-appellants, v. Commisioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent-appellee
204 F.3d 776 Feb 22, 2000 Seventh United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Michael L. Morris, Defendant-appellant
204 F.3d 780 Feb 22, 2000 Seventh Henry Green, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Kenneth S. Apfel, Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 783 Feb 17, 2000 Eighth Harry Tucker, Plaintiff-appellant, v. City of Hot Springs, Arkansas, Defendant-appellee
204 F.3d 784 Feb 18, 2000 Eighth Darrell D. Whitmore, Appellant, v. Dennis Michael Harrington; Mark Braden, Appellees
204 F.3d 785 Jan 10, 2000 Eighth Marilyn Kitts, Appellant, v. Kenneth S. Apfel, Commissioner Social Security Administration, Appellee