Justia Federal District Court Opinions

Citation	Date	Circuit	Parties
372 F.3d 1	Dec 02, 2003	First	In Re Holyoke Nursing Home, Inc., Debtor,holyoke Nursing Home, Inc., Appellant, v. Health Care Financing Administration, Appellee
372 F.3d 6	Oct 09, 2003	First	United States of America, Appellee, v. Elvin Tomás Morales-de Jesús, Defendant, Appellant
372 F.3d 22	Mar 02, 2004	First	United States of America, Appellee, v. Victor Pagan-ortega, Defendant, Appellant
372 F.3d 31	Mar 04, 2004	First	Sunoco, Inc. (r & M), Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Naif Makol, Jr., and Makol Family Limited Partnership, Defendants, Appellees
372 F.3d 39	Apr 06, 2004	First	Peter J. Limone et al., Plaintiffs, Appellees, v. Dennis Condon et al., Defendants, Appellants
372 F.3d 52	Apr 09, 2004	First	Thomas J. Harrington; Richard S. Neville; Thomas Fordham; Francis J. Ferguson; John A. Biggins; Mark J. Durkin, Plaintiffs, Appellees,joseph D. Flemming, Iii, Plaintiff, v. Elaine L. Chao, Secretary of Labor, Defendant, Appellant
372 F.3d 75	May 07, 2004	Second	United States of America, Appellee, v. Robert Khimchiachvili, Also Known As Prince Robert, Also Known As Dr. Von Badische; Cesar A. Viana; Christopher Berwick, Defendants,brian D. Sherry, Also Known As Colonel Sherry, Also Known As Major Sherry, Also Known As Sir Brian Sherry, Also Known As Prince Brian, Also Known As Brian Sherry-berwick, George R. Englert, Also Known As Dr. Moncrieffe, Also Known As Baron Moncrieffe, Also Known As Prince George; Cesar A. Viana; Christopher Berwick, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 83	Mar 21, 2003	Second	Paul A. Krohn, Plaintiff-appellee-cross-appellant,alli Katt, Plaintiff-appellee, v. New York City Police Department and Anthony Dipalma, Defendants-appellants-cross-appellees
372 F.3d 86	Jan 23, 2004	Second	United States of America, Appellee, v. Carlos Lopez, Also Known As Charlie Chan, Also Known As Chan; Rafael Lopez, Also Known As Tito, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 96	Feb 25, 2004	Second	United States of America, Appellee, v. David Williams, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 113	Feb 02, 2004	Second	United States of America, Appellee, v. Eugene Chusid, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 118	Jan 26, 2004	Second	United States of America, Appellee, v. Scott Ansaldi, Rodney Dean Gates, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 132	Oct 06, 2003	Second	Eric Adams, Petitioner-appellant, v. United States of America, Respondent-appellee
372 F.3d 137	Jun 16, 2003	Third	In Re: Alpharma Inc. Securities Litigationmaverick Capital, Ltd., Appellant
372 F.3d 154	Oct 29, 2003	Third	In Re: Resorts International, Inc., Resorts International Financing, Inc., Griffin Resorts, Inc., Resorts Holding, Inc., Debtorsj. Louis Binder, As Trustee of the Resorts International, Inc. Litigation Trust v. Price Waterhouse & Co., Llp, Appellant
372 F.3d 171	Feb 12, 2004	Third	Avon Contractors, Inc., Petitioner v. Secretary of Labor; Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission, Respondents
372 F.3d 175	Apr 21, 2004	Third	Elinor F. Marshall; Harriet Fenton Parks; Caroll D. Knott; Lindsay Dryden, Iii; Randolph Fenton, Jr.; Glenn Thornton; Syndie Thornton Smith; Heather Thornton; Matthew C. Fenton, Iii Thomas T. Fenton, Appellants v. Bruce Lea Lauriault; Mercantile-safe Deposit & Trust Company; K. Donald Proctor; Elizabeth Chandler Lauriault Pierson; Sally Vaughn Lauriault
372 F.3d 188	May 07, 2004	Third	Orlando Tavarez, Appellant v. Allan Klingensmith
372 F.3d 193	Sep 16, 2003	Third	Orrin T. Skretvedt, Appellant v. E.i. Dupont De Nemours, a Delaware Corporation; Pension and Retirement Plan; Hospital and Medical-surgical Plan; Dental Assistance Plan; Noncontributory Group Life Insurance Plan; Contributory Group Life Insurance Plan; Total and Permanent Disability Income Plan; Savings Investment Plan; Tax Reform Act Stock Ownership Plan; Short Term Disability Plan
372 F.3d 218	Jan 13, 2004	Third	Robert Spruill, Appellant v. Frank Gillis; Goolier, C.o.; Mcglaughlin, M.d.; Brown, P.a
372 F.3d 238	Feb 25, 2004	Fourth	Melvin Sidwell, Petitioner, v. Virginia International Terminals, Inc.; Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, United States Department of Labor, Respondents
372 F.3d 245	Dec 03, 2003	Fourth	South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control; Ameristeel; Roanoke Electric Steel Corporation; Owens Electric Steel; Nucor Steel; Nucor Yamato; the Federal Metal Company; I. Schumann & Company; Cp Chemicals, Incorporated; Kerr-mcgee Chemical Llc; Lucent Technologies, Incorporated; Mueller Brass Company, Plaintiffs-appellants, Andgaston Copper Recycling Corporation, Plaintiff, v. Commerce and Industry Insurance Company; United States Fire Insurance Company; Jefferson Insurance Company; the South Carolina Property and Casualty Insurance Guaranty Association, A/k/a Mutual Fire Marine and Inland Insurance Company, Defendants-appellees.complex Insurance Claims Litigation Association, Amicus Supporting Appellees
372 F.3d 261	May 04, 2004	Fourth	Alan Meyer, Trustee for Paul D. Meyer, M.d., P.a.; Jorge R. Ordonez, Trustee for Jorge R. Ordonez, M.d., P.a.; Employee Profit Sharing Plan and Trust, Successor to Jorge R. Ordonez, M.d. Money Purchase Pension Plan and Trust; Money Purchase Plan and Trust, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Berkshire Life Insurance Company, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 267	Dec 03, 2003	Fourth	Destiny Owens, a Minor Under the Age of Fourteen Years, by and Through Her Mother and Guardian Ad Litem, Latanya Owens; Leshia Donaldson; William Clayton; Gregory Owens, a Minor Under the Age of Fourteen Years, by and Through His Mother and Guardian Ad Litem, Latanya Owens; Latanya Owens, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Leon Lott, Richland County Sheriff; J. Maldonado; Jane Doe; Richard Doe, Richland County Deputy Sheriffs, Defendants-appellees.destiny Owens, a Minor Under the Age of Fourteen Years, by and Through Her Mother and Guardian Ad Litem, Latanya Owens; Leshia Donaldson; William Clayton; Gregory Owens, a Minor Under the Age of Fourteen Years, by and Through His Mother and Guardian Ad Litem, Latanya Owens; Latanya Owens, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Leon Lott, Richland County Sheriff; J. Maldonado; Jane Doe; Richard Doe, Richland County Deputy Sheriffs, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 281	Apr 01, 2003	Fourth	No. 02-1271
372 F.3d 286	May 05, 2004	Fourth	Mark E. Hanson, Esq., Plaintiff-appellant, v. United States Agency for International Development, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 294	Oct 30, 2003	Fourth	No. 02-2306
372 F.3d 326	May 28, 2004	Fifth	Felicia Shepherd, Alex Grisby, Melvin Jackson, Gerald Thomas, Claudine Falkner, Rufino Razo, David Criswell, Larry Oliver, Michael Cloudy, Mark Fletcher, Quincy Ratcliff and Randy Horn, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. International Paper Co., Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 339	Jun 11, 2004	Fifth	Waste Management, Inc., Plaintiff-appellee, v. Residuos Industriales Multiquim, S.a. De C. v. , Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 346	Oct 30, 2003	Sixth	Charles E. Austin et al., Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Reginald Wilkinson et al., Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 365	Mar 10, 2004	Sixth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Erik Bowker, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 395	May 17, 2004	DC	California Independent System Operator Corporation, Petitioner, v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Respondent.duke Energy North America, Llc, et al., Intervenors
372 F.3d 404	Feb 20, 2004	DC	Bluewater Network, Petitioner, v. Environmental Protection Agency and Michael O. Leavitt, Administrator, United States Environmental Protection Agency, Respondents
372 F.3d 413	Mar 16, 2004	DC	In Re: American Rivers and Idaho Rivers United, Petitioners
372 F.3d 420	Feb 10, 2004	DC	Independent Equipment Dealers Association, Petitioner, v. Environmental Protection Agency, Respondent.engine Manufacturers Association, Intervenor
372 F.3d 429	May 11, 2004	DC	Bow G. Jung, Appellant, v. Mundy, Holt & Mance, P.c. and Reginald L. Holt, Appellees
372 F.3d 434	May 17, 2004	DC	Viola J. Keyes, Appellant, v. District of Columbia and Carolyn Graham, Deputy Mayor for Children and Families Interim Director Department of Human Services, in Her Individual Capacity, Appellees
372 F.3d 441	Apr 07, 2004	DC	Honeywell International, Inc. and Edgewater Working Group, Petitioners, v. Environmental Protection Agency and Michael O. Leavitt, Administrator, United States Environmental Protection Agency, Respondents
372 F.3d 451	May 10, 2004	DC	Raytheon Company, Appellant, v. Ashborn Agencies, Ltd., Appellee
372 F.3d 454	Nov 24, 2003	DC	National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates, Petitioner, v. Federal Communications Commission and United States of America, Respondents.bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., et al., Intervenors
372 F.3d 462	Feb 12, 2004	DC	United States of America, Appellee, v. Lydell Ellerbe, Appellant
372 F.3d 470	May 26, 2004	First	United States, Appellee, v. Bernard Lewandowski, Defendant, Appellant
372 F.3d 471	Jan 26, 2004	Second	Capitol Records, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant, v. Naxos of America, Inc., Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 485	Apr 14, 2004	Second	Ivan Rodriguez, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Westchester County Jail Correctional Department, Assoc. Warden Miranda, Emergency Response Team (ert), Westchester County Jail, Sgt. Gary Johnson, Supervisor, Ert, Officer Rosendorn, John Doe-1, John Doe-2, Emsa Correctional Care, Defendants-appellees
372 F.3d 488	Feb 05, 2004	Second	Pennecom B. v. , Plaintiff-appellant, v. Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc., Merrill Lynch International, Inc. and Paul A. Pittman, Defendants-appellees
372 F.3d 495	May 11, 2004	Second	Gregory Gelman, Petitioner, v. John Ashcroft, United States Attorney General, Respondent
372 F.3d 500	Apr 12, 2004	Second	State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., Plaintiff-appellant, v. Robert Mallela, Tatiana Rybuk, Paul Schneider, Advance Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, P.c., D/b/a Mill Basin Physical Medicine, Ridgewood Medical Specialist and Hempstead Village Medical, Allied Medical Health Care, P.c., Astoria Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, P.c., Atlantic Medical Practice, P.c., Avenue U Medical Services, P.c., Bay Medical Health Care & Diagnostic, P.c., Bettercare Health Pain and Management, P.c., D/b/a Firstcare of Bettercare Healthcare, Canarsie Medical Services, P.c., Central Medical Rehabilitation, P.c., Central Suffolk Medical Services, P.c., Citywide Medical Practice, P.c., Daka Medical, P.c., D/b/a Island Health Professionals, Farragut Medical Care, P.c., First Queens Physical Med. and Rehabilitation, P.c., Flatbush Medical Services, P.c., Fordham Medical Pain and Treatment, P.c., Franklin Medical Rehab., P.c., Grand Central Healthcare and Physical Medicine, P.c., Health First Medical Practice, P.c.,
372 F.3d 510	Jun 16, 2003	Third	In the Matter Of: Tops Appliance City, Inc., Debtordonald v. Biase, Trustee in Bankruptcy for Tops Appliance City, Inc., v. Congress Financial Corporation, Donald v. Biase, Appellant
372 F.3d 517	Oct 27, 2003	Third	Jeffrey Justofin, Christopher Justofin; Damian Justofin; Robert Justofin; Ivan Justofin, (beneficiaries of Loretta K. Justofin, Deceased), Appellants v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co
372 F.3d 529	Dec 04, 2003	Third	Gui Cun Liu; Xiu Ding Liu, Petitioners v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General of United States of America, Respondent
372 F.3d 535	Mar 24, 2004	Third	United States of America v. Christine Annemarie Lennon, Christine A. Lennon, Appellant
372 F.3d 543	Mar 29, 2004	Third	United States of America v. Chris Rutland Christopher H. Rutland, Appellant
372 F.3d 546	Apr 20, 2004	Third	Elizabeth Ramirez Appellant, v. Joanne B. Barnhart, Commissioner of Social Security Administration
372 F.3d 556	May 11, 2004	Third	John J. Matsko, Iii; Teresa A. Matsko, Husband and Wife, Appellants v. United States of America; Rudy Kotor
372 F.3d 562	May 14, 2004	Third	United States of America v. Shawn L. Poellnitz, Appellant
372 F.3d 572	Apr 16, 2004	Third	A.m., by and Through His Next Friend and Mother, J.m.k., Appellant v. Luzerne County Juvenile Detention Center, a Department of Luzerne County, Pennsylvania; *sandra M. Brulo, Individually and in Her Official Capacity As Chief Administrator of the Luzerne County Juvenile Detention Center; Louis P. Kwarcinski, Individually and in His Official Capacity As Deputy Chief Probation Officer in Charge of the Luzerne County Juvenile Detention Center; Jerome Prawdzik, in His Individual Capacity; Christopher Traver, in His Individual Capacity; Christopher Parker, in His Individual Capacity; Michael Considine, in His Individual Capacity; Mark Puffenberger, M.d., in His Official Capacity; Elaine Yozviak, R.n., in Her Individual Capacity.*(amended Per Clerk's Order Dated 8/14/03)
372 F.3d 588	Jan 12, 2004	Third	Margaret Palcko v. Airborne Express, Inc., Appellant
372 F.3d 598	Dec 09, 2003	Third	Gte Corporation, Appellant v. Allendale Mutual Insurance Company; Affiliated Fm Insurance Company; Allianz Insurance Company; Federal Insurance Company; Industrial Risk Insurers
372 F.3d 618	Jan 12, 2004	Third	Shirley Mcleod, Appellant v. Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company; Group Long Term Disability Benefits for Employees of Valley Media, Inc; Valley Media, Inc
372 F.3d 629	May 07, 2004	Fourth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. John Mark Collins, Defendant-appellant.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Robert Marshall Serrano, Defendant-appellant.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. John Mark Collins; Robert Marshall Serrano, Defendants-appellees
372 F.3d 637	May 05, 2004	Fourth	In Re: Harford Sands Inc; Harford Industrial Minerals, Incorporated, Debtors.terry D. Stancill; Jerry Stancill; Timothy K. Stancill; Timothy D. Stancill, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Harford Sands Inc, Debtor-appellee
372 F.3d 643	Jan 21, 2004	Fourth	Latisha S. Castillo, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Emergency Medicine Associates, P.a., Defendant-appellee, Andjohn/jane Doe, Md; Prince William Hospital, Defendants
372 F.3d 653	Jan 22, 2004	Fourth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Deunte L. Humphries, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 662	Dec 05, 2003	Fourth	Jesse J. Williams, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Staples, Incorporated, D/b/a the Office Superstore Staples, Incorporated, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 671	Jun 24, 2004	Fourth	Psinet, Incorporated; Charlottesville Sexual Health & Wellness Clinic; Portico Publications, Ltd., Publisher of Charlottesville Weekly; Silverchair Science Communications, Incorporated; Virginia Isp Alliance; Rockbridge Global Village; American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression; the Periodical and Book Association of America, Incorporated; Freedom to Read Foundation; Sexual Health Network; Chris Filkins, Proprietor of the Safer Sex Institute; Harlan Ellison; the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund; Susie Bright; a Different Light Bookstores; Lambda Rising Bookstores; Bibliobytes; People for the American Way, Plaintiffs-appellees, Andunited States Internet Service Provider Association, Plaintiff, v. Warren D. Chapman, Commonwealth Attorney; James L. Cambloss, Iii, Commonwealth Attorney, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 674	Jan 22, 2004	Fourth	Aw,1 by His Parents, Debra D. Wilson and Christopher D. Wilson, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Fairfax County School Board, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 686	Jan 21, 2004	Fourth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Robert Kennedy, Jr., Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 706	Jun 01, 2004	Fifth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Darrell Keith Crittenden, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 714	Jun 03, 2004	Fifth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Ahmed Koffi Henry, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 717	Jun 03, 2004	Fifth	International Truck and Engine Corporation, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Brett Bray, in His Official Capacity As the Director of the Motor Vehicle Division of the Texas Department of Transportation and Chief Executive and Administrative Officer of the Motor Vehicle Board of the Texas Department of Transportation, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 729	Jun 04, 2004	Fifth	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. James Edward Frye, Also Known As Sealed Defendant 2, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 742	Jun 04, 2004	Fifth	Judy Hudson, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Forest Oil Corp.; Zurich American Insurance Co., Defendants-appellees, v. Ace American Indemnity Insurance Co., Doing Business As Montlake Casualty Co., Intervenor-appellant
372 F.3d 748	Jun 07, 2004	Fifth	Dennis Wayne Bagwell, Petitioner-appellant, v. Douglas Dretke, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice — Correctional Institutions Division, Respondent-appellee
372 F.3d 757	Jun 08, 2004	Fifth	Amanda S. May, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Higbee Company, Doing Business As Dillard's; William Carr, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 765	Jun 22, 2004	Fifth	David Grillette, Petitioner-appellant, v. Warden, Winn Correctional Center, Respondent-appellee
372 F.3d 776	Feb 06, 2004	Sixth	David Aaron Tenenbaum; Madeline Gail Tenenbaum, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. John Simonini, Lt. Col.; Albert D. Snyder; Mark P. Yourchock; Robert M. Riley, Individually and in Their Representative Capacities As Employees for the Various Federal Agencies That Employ Them; and the United States of America, Defendants-appellees
372 F.3d 778	Dec 04, 2003	Sixth	Arthur L. Armstrong, Petitioner-appellant, v. Jack Morgan, Warden, Respondent-appellee
372 F.3d 784	Apr 27, 2004	Sixth	Rita Sanders Geier; Patrick J. Gilpin; Ernest Terrell; Harold Sweatt; Phillip Sweatt, Individually and As Next Friend of Phillip Sweatt; Citizens and Residents of the State of Tennessee; Citizens of the United States, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Don Sundquist, et al., Defendants-appellees
372 F.3d 798	Mar 16, 2004	Sixth	Mcwane, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant/cross-appellee, v. Fidelity & Deposit Company of Maryland, Defendant-appellee/cross-appellant,grooms Construction Company, Inc.; Highland County Water Company, Inc., Defendants
372 F.3d 807	Mar 12, 2003	Sixth	Wilson Air Center, Llc, Petitioner, v. Federal Aviation Administration, Respondent,memphis-shelby County Airport Authority, Intervenor
372 F.3d 821	Oct 29, 2003	Sixth	Billy Joe Sowell, Petitioner-appellee, v. Margaret Bradshaw, Warden, Respondent-appellant
372 F.3d 842	Apr 29, 2004	Sixth	Networktwo Communications Group, Inc., Plaintiff/counter-defendant/appellee, v. Spring Valley Marketing Group and Communityisp, Inc., Defendants/counter-plaintiffs/appellants
372 F.3d 848	Sep 17, 2003	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Durriel E. Gillaum, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 862	Nov 04, 2003	Seventh	Deborah Petersen, Plaintiff-appellee, Cross-appellant, v. Byron Gibson, Officer, Defendant-appellant, Cross-appellee
372 F.3d 868	Jan 07, 2003	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Angelo Cassano, Norman "randy" Williams, and Clarence Cross, Defendants-appellants
372 F.3d 886	Jun 08, 2004	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Northern Trust Company, As Trustee of the Caterpillar Incorporated Master Trust and the Inland Steel Industries Pension Trust, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 890	Apr 14, 2004	Seventh	Harry L. Maynard, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Keith Nygren, Not Individually but As Sheriff of Mchenry County, Illinois, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 894	Jan 15, 2004	Seventh	Pamela Johnson, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Larabida Children's Hospital, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 899	Jun 08, 2004	Seventh	Xechem, Inc., and Xechem International, Inc., Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Bristol-myers Squibb Company, Defendant-appellee
372 F.3d 903	May 17, 2004	Seventh	Roy Carbajal, Plaintiff-appellant, v. H & R Block Tax Services, Inc., et al., Defendants-appellees
372 F.3d 907	Jan 09, 2004	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Elizabeth R. Roach, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 910	Feb 26, 2004	Seventh	United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. William J. Jones, Defendant-appellant
372 F.3d 913	Jun 06, 2003	Seventh	Pivot Point International, Incorporated, Plaintiff-appellant, Cross-appellee, v. Charlene Products, Incorporated and Peter Yau, Defendants-appellees, Cross-appellants
372 F.3d 935	Feb 12, 2004	Eighth	United States of America, Appellant, v. Jesus Ramirez-marquez, Appellee
372 F.3d 941	May 14, 2004	Eighth	Dimitri Prokopenko, Petitioner, v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United States, Respondent
372 F.3d 946	May 10, 2004	Eighth	Larry Reutter, on Behalf of Destiny Reutter, Plaintiff-appellee/cross-appellant, v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart, Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant-appellant/cross-appellee
372 F.3d 953	Mar 12, 2004	Eighth	United States of America, Appellee, v. Rafael Arrieta-buendia, Appellant
372 F.3d 956	Mar 12, 2004	Eighth	Maureen Slater, Plaintiff — Appellant, v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart, Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant — Appellee
372 F.3d 958	Mar 11, 2004	Eighth	Gregory Kelley, Plaintiff — Appellant, v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart, Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant — Appellee
372 F.3d 962	Apr 15, 2004	Eighth	Donna S. Sheehan, Appellee/cross-appellant, v. Guardian Life Insurance Company, Appellant/cross-appellee