154 Cases, Displaying Page 1 of 1
Citation Date Circuit Parties
427 F.3d 1 Sep 16, 2005 DC Kidd Communications, Appellant v. Federal Communications Commission, Appelleeparadise Broadcasting, Inc., Intervenor
427 F.3d 7 Sep 09, 2005 DC Irene Branham, As Next Friend of the Minor Child Terrance Branham, Appellee v. the Government of the District of Columbia, Appellant
427 F.3d 14 Sep 15, 2005 First James R. Muirhead, Plaintiff, Appellant, v. L. Ralph Mecham, Director, Administrative Office of the United States Courts, Defendant, Appellee
427 F.3d 21 Aug 05, 2005 First Puerto Rico Telephone Company, Inc., As Liquidator on Behalf of Reliance Insurance Co. (in Liquidation), Plaintiff, Appellant/cross-appellee, v. U.S. Phone Manufacturing Corporation, Defendant, Appellee/cross-appellant
427 F.3d 34 Sep 16, 2005 First Global Naps, Inc., Plaintiff, Appellee/cross-appellant, v. Massachusetts Department of Telecommunications and Energy; Paul B. Vasington, in His Capacity As Commissioner; James Connelly, in His Capacity As Commissioner; W. Robert Keating, in His Capacity As Commissioner; Deirdre K. Manning, in Her Capacity As Commissioner; Eugene J. Sullivan, in His Capacity As Commissioner; and Verizon New England, Inc., Defendants, Appellants/cross-appellees
427 F.3d 49 Sep 13, 2005 First In Re Public Offering Ple Antitrust Litigation.jeffrey A. Weinman, As Trustee for Western Pacific Airlines; Equalnet Communications Corporation, Appellants, v. Stuart Cable, Appellee
427 F.3d 53 Sep 13, 2005 First United States of America, Appellee, v. Jean Brito, Defendant, Appellant
427 F.3d 69 Aug 01, 2005 First United States of America, Appellee, v. Imauri Ivery, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 76 Sep 14, 2005 First No. 05-1205
427 F.3d 80 Sep 14, 2005 First Mohammad Adnan Kheireddine; Hassane Adnan Kheireddine, Petitioners, v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States, Respondent
427 F.3d 88 Oct 06, 2005 First United States of America, Appellee, v. Edgar Medina, Defendant, Appellant
427 F.3d 93 Sep 15, 2005 First Puerto Rico Ports Authority, Petitioner, Appellant, v. Barge Katy-b, O.n. 606665, Defendant in Rem.salmon Bay Barge Line, Inc., Intervenor, Appellee
427 F.3d 108 Sep 14, 2005 First Frederick Feddersen, Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Carolyn S. Garvey, Esq.; and Douglas, Leonard & Garvey, P.a., Defendants, Appellees
427 F.3d 115 Sep 22, 2005 First Edward Dirk Nikijuluw, Petitioner, v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States, Respondent
427 F.3d 122 Oct 03, 2005 First United States of America, Appellee, v. Fredrico Tavares, Defendant, Appellant
427 F.3d 127 Oct 04, 2005 First Elaine Connolly, Plaintiff, Appellant, v. H.d. Goodall Hospital, Inc.; Shelly Stuart; Jeffrey Toner; Dolores Hopper, Defendants, Appellees
427 F.3d 129 Aug 03, 2005 First Roger Edwards, Llc, Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Fiddes & Son Ltd., Defendant, Appellee
427 F.3d 137 May 04, 2005 First United States of America, Appellee, v. Tijani Momoh, Defendant, Appellant
427 F.3d 144 Jan 05, 2005 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Samuel Yakobowicz, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 158 Oct 06, 2005 Second Kevin Murphy, Administrator of the Estate of Lawrence Martin Payne, et al., Plaintiffs-appellants, v. United States of America, et al., Defendants-appellees.docket No. 04-6265-cv
427 F.3d 159 May 19, 2005 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Ibrahim Kurti, Defendant-appellant.[do] Docket No. 04-2239-cr
427 F.3d 164 Sep 14, 2005 Second United States of America, Appellee, v. Shlomo Cohen, Defendant-appellant,eliase Shtoukhamer, Defendant
427 F.3d 172 Mar 02, 2005 Second New York Public Interest Research Group, Inc., Petitioner, v. Stephen L. Johnson, in His Capacity As Administrator, United States Environmental Protection Agency* Respondent
427 F.3d 186 May 25, 2005 Second Andrea Cerra, Parent of Kathryn C., a Disabled Student and Thomas Cerra, Parent of Kathryn C., a Disabled Student Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Pawling Central School District Defendant-appellant.docket No. 04-5370-cv
427 F.3d 197 Mar 08, 2005 Third James G. Gilles; Timothy Petit Appellants v. Sergeant Gregory Davis, Indiana University Police Department; Officer Christopher D. Goenner, Indiana University Police Department; Terry Appolonia, Director, Student Life, Indiana University of Pennsylvania; Rhonda H. Luckey, Ed.d., Associate President of Student Affairs for Indiana University of Pennsylvania; William Montgomery, Director of Public Safety, Indiana University of Pennsylvania
427 F.3d 219 Jun 30, 2005 Third United States of America, v. Lane Labs-usa Inc, a Corporation; Andrew J. Lane, an Individual, Appellants
427 F.3d 236 Jul 11, 2005 Third Galen Reichley, T/d/b/a Reichley Brothers Farm; Allen Reichley, T/d/b/a Reichley Brothers Farm; Curtis Stroup v. Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture; Penn Ag Industries; Longenecker's Hatchery, Inc.; Kreamer Feed, Inc.; Dennis C. Wolff; Samuel E. Hayes, As Secretary of the Pa Department of Agriculture Galen Reichley, Allen Reichley T/d/b/a/ Reichley Brothers Farm and Curtis Stroup, Appellants
427 F.3d 248 Sep 15, 2004 Third Syed Mahmood, Petitioner v. *alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States, Respondent
427 F.3d 253 Oct 18, 2005 Fourth Steven J. Hatfill, Plaintiff—appellant, v. the New York Times Company, Defendant—appellee, Andnicholas Kristof, Defendant
427 F.3d 259 Sep 20, 2005 Fourth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Antroyne J. Barnette, A/k/a Black, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 263 Feb 01, 2005 Fourth Roland A. Thompson, Petitioner-appellant, v. Kathleen Greene; Attorney General for the State of Maryland, Respondents-appellees
427 F.3d 271 Sep 20, 2005 Fourth Captain Sheriff Saudi, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Northrop Grumman Corporation; Newport News Shipbuilding, Incorporated; Keppel Group Corporation, D/b/a Keppel Offshore & Marine, Limited, D/b/a Keppel Shipyard (pte), Ltd., Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 280 Sep 21, 2005 Fifth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Eric Del Barrio, Also Known As Andy Lopez, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 285 Sep 29, 2005 Fifth Douglas Spector, et al., Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Norwegian Cruise Line Ltd., Doing Business As Norwegian Cruise Line, Defendant-appellee.douglas Spector, et al., Defendants-appellees, v. Norwegian Cruise Line Ltd., Doing Business As Norwegian Cruise Line, Plaintiff-appellant
427 F.3d 286 Sep 30, 2005 Fifth Martin Allen Draughon, Petitioner-appellee-cross-appellant, v. Doug Dretke, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Respondent-appellant-cross-appellee
427 F.3d 298 Sep 30, 2005 Fifth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Samuel Saldana, Jr., Defendant-appellant.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Saul Saldana, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 316 Oct 03, 2005 Fifth Seferina Rodriguez-castro, Petitioner, v. Alberto R. Gonzales, United States Attorney General, Respondent
427 F.3d 324 Aug 09, 2005 Sixth Ilir Shkabari; Orjeta Shkabari; Klidis Shkabari, Petitioners, v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General, Respondent
427 F.3d 332 Sep 16, 2005 Sixth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Victor Manuel Ibarra-hernandez, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 336 Jul 28, 2005 Sixth Sidney Coal Company, Inc., et al., Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Social Security Administration, Defendant-appellant (04-6286),michael H. Holland, et al., Intervenors Defendants-appellants (04-6291)
427 F.3d 351 Jun 01, 2005 Sixth J. Richard Ernst, William T. Ervin, James E. Wilson, and John Patrick O'brien, on Behalf of Themselves and All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Jay B. Rising, Treasurer of the State of Michigan; Christopher M. Derose, Director, Department of Management and Budget Office of Retirement Systems; George M. Elworth, Member, Michigan Judges Retirement Board; Mark Haas, Member, Michigan Judges Retirement Board; Alton Davis, Member, Michigan Judges Retirement Board; Francis Spaniola, Member, Michigan Judges Retirement Board; and Chris J. Swope, Member, Michigan Judges Retirement Board, Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 382 Sep 22, 2005 Sixth Lillie Horton, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Ford Motor Company; Ford Motor Company Defined Benefit Master Trust; Ford Motor Company Uaw Retirement Plan, Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 388 Sep 22, 2005 Sixth John M. Valley, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 394 Mar 15, 2005 Sixth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. J. Richard Jamieson, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 419 Aug 03, 2005 Seventh Kevin Korczak, et al., Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Faizel Sedeman, et al., Defendants-appellees.appeal of Tarkwin Enrick
427 F.3d 423 Mar 29, 2005 Seventh United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Allan Johnson, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 429 Jun 07, 2005 Seventh Ruben Cardoso, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Robert Bosch Corporation, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 436 Jan 05, 2005 Seventh Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center, Also Known As Michael Reese Health Trust, and Strategic Reimbursement, Incorporated, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Tommy G. Thompson, Not Individually but in His Capacity As Secretary of the United States Department of Health and Human Services, and Adminastar Federal, Incorporated, Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 446 Oct 07, 2005 Seventh James Brill, Plaintiff-respondent, v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., Defendant-petitioner
427 F.3d 452 Sep 22, 2005 Seventh Ira Shyman, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Unum Life Insurance Co., Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 456 Sep 14, 2005 Seventh Joseph Jaskolski and National Insurance Crime Bureau, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Rick Daniels, et al., Defendants-appellants
427 F.3d 464 Oct 21, 2005 Seventh United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, Cross-appellee, v. Criss E. Duncan, Defendant-appellee, Cross-appellant
427 F.3d 466 Sep 22, 2005 Seventh Jenny Wernsing, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Department of Human Services, State of Illinois, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 471 May 04, 2005 Seventh United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Timothy J. Julian, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 492 Apr 08, 2005 Seventh Maria Dolores Cuellar Lopez, Petitioner, v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States, Respondent
427 F.3d 498 Sep 13, 2005 Seventh Anthony Horton, Petitioner-appellant, v. Jon E. Litscher, Secretary, Wisconsin Department of Corrections, Respondent-appellee
427 F.3d 508 Sep 07, 2005 Seventh Ghulam Murtuza,1 Petitioner, v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Respondent
427 F.3d 511 Apr 14, 2005 Eighth Ruzicka Electric and Sons, Inc.; Thomas R. Ruzicka, Appellants, v. International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 1, Afl-cio, Appellee
427 F.3d 525 Mar 16, 2005 Eighth Heartland Academy Community Church, a Missouri Not-for-profit Corporation; Cns International Ministries, Inc., a Missouri Not-for-profit Corporation; Tracy Leftwich; David Christensen; Becky Christensen; Paula Mckinney; Del Mckinney; Jennifer Armstead; Peggy White; Sam Perumalla; Sheela Perumalla; Jim Brownfield; Cheryl Crary; Jim Crary; David Lawson; Marilyn Lawson; Susan Mccloy; John Mccloy; Denver Barry Selser; Ross Dale; Tina Dale; Shawn Jarnigan; Amy Jarnigan; Brad Hampton; Martha Hampton, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. Michael Waddle, in His Individual and Official Capacities, Defendant-appellant,david Parrish, in His Individual and Official Capacities; Patricia Mcafee, in Her Individual and Official Capacities; Lewis County, Missouri; Missouri Department of Social Services; Cindy Kennel Ayers, in Her Individual and Official Capacities, Defendants
427 F.3d 537 Oct 23, 2003 Eighth United States of America, Appellee, v. Robert Lee Norman, Also Known As Skunk, Appellant.united States of America, Appellee/cross Appellant, v. Russell J. Schoenauer, Appellant/cross-appellee
427 F.3d 541 Sep 12, 2005 Eighth Iowa Protection and Advocacy Services, Plaintiff/appellee,united States of America, Intervenor on Appeal, v. Tanager, Inc.; Tanager Place, Defendants/appellants.association of Protection & Advocacy Systems, Inc.; the American Association on Mental Retardation; the Arc of the United States; the Federation of Families for Children's Mental Health; the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill; the National Association of Councils on Developmental Disabilities; the National Mental Health Association, Amici on Behalf of Appellee
427 F.3d 544 Apr 11, 2005 Eighth Darold Maxfield, Appellant, v. Cintas Corporation No. 2, Appellee
427 F.3d 554 Sep 21, 2005 Eighth United States of America, Appellee, v. Demario A. Howard, Appellant
427 F.3d 558 Sep 21, 2005 Eighth United States of America, Appellee, v. Ronald Dean Meyer, Appellant
427 F.3d 562 Sep 13, 2005 Eighth United States of America, Appellee, v. Elias Zavala, Also Known As Shannon Estrada, Also Known As Francisco Alvarez-estrada, Appellant
427 F.3d 567 Jul 14, 2004 Ninth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Jose Luis Ortiz-hernandez, Defendant-appellee.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Jose Luis Ortiz-hernandez, Defendant-appellee.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Jose Luis Ortiz-hernandez, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 586 Dec 09, 2004 Ninth Emma Altamirano, Petitioner, v. Alberto R. Gonzales,* Attorney General, Respondent
427 F.3d 597 Jun 13, 2005 Ninth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Alisal Water Corporation; Toro Water Service, Inc.; North Monterey County Water Service, Inc.; Moss Landing Water Service, Inc.; Natholyn P. Adcock; Robert T. Adcock, Defendants-appellants.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Alisal Water Corporation; Toro Water Service, Inc.; Robert T. Adcock; North Monterey County Water Service, Inc.; Moss Landing Water Service, Inc.; Natholyn P. Adcock, Defendants-appellants, Andpatricia Adcock; Bruce Pierson; David M. Simcho, Defendants,john W. Richardson, Receiver
427 F.3d 615 Oct 04, 2004 Ninth The Arc of Washington State Inc., a Washington Corporation on Behalf of Its Members; Guadalupe E. Cano, by and Through Her Guardian Delia C. Cano; Olivia Murguia, by and Through Her Guardian Teri L. Hewett; Lorianne v. Ludwigson, by and Through Her Guardians Donald and Sheryl Ludwigson, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Dennis Braddock, in His Official Capacity As the Secretary of the Washington Department of Social and Health Services;* Department of Social & Health Services State of Washington; Financial Management Office of the State of Washington; Marty Brown, in His Official Capacity As Director of the Washington Office of Financial Management; Timothy R. Brown, in His Official Capacity As the Director of the Washington State Division of Developmental Disabilities; Developmental Disabilities Division; Christine Gregoire,** in Her Capacity As Governor of the State of Washington, Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 622 Oct 14, 2005 Ninth Violeta Circu, Petitioner, v. Alberto R. Gonzales,* Attorney General, Respondent
427 F.3d 623 Mar 22, 2005 Ninth Warren Wesley Summerlin, Petitioner-appellant, v. Dora B. Schriro, Director of Arizona Department of Corrections, Respondent-appellee
427 F.3d 646 Oct 20, 2005 Ninth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Hossein Afshari, Aka Hosseini Deklami; Mohammad Omidvar; Hassan Rezaie; Roya Rahmani, Aka Sister Tahmineh; Navid Taj, Aka Najaf Eshkoftegi; Mustafa Ahmady; Alireza Mohamad Moradi, Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 647 Oct 21, 2005 Ninth Mathew Musladin, Petitioner-appellant, v. Anthony Lamarque, Warden, Respondent-appellee
427 F.3d 653 Nov 02, 2004 Ninth Mathew Musladin, Petitioner-appellant, v. Anthony Lamarque, Warden, Respondent-appellee
427 F.3d 663 Oct 24, 2005 Ninth Fernando Belmontes, Jr., Petitioner-appellant, v. John Stokes, Warden, for the California State Prison at San Quentin,* Respondent-appellee
427 F.3d 668 Nov 04, 2004 Ninth Jeffrey H. Beck, Liquidating Trustee of the Estates of Crown Vantage, Inc. and Crown Paper Company, Appellant, v. Pace International Union, on Behalf of Member and Former Member Participants in Pension Plans Sponsored by the Debtors; Edward Miller; Jeffrey D. Macek, on Behalf of Themselves and Others Similarly Situated, Defendants-appellees.pace International Union, Afl-cio, Chemical & Energy Workers International Union, on Behalf of Members and Former Member Participants in Pension Plans, Defendant-appellant, v. Jeffrey H. Beck, Liquidating Trustee of the Estates of Crown Vantage, Inc. and Crown Paper Company, Appellee
427 F.3d 680 Jul 14, 2005 Ninth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Dean Lafromboise, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 688 Feb 07, 2005 Ninth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Gwaine Collins, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 693 Jan 10, 2005 Ninth Kykhosro Notash, Petitioner, v. Alberto R. Gonzales,* Attorney General, Respondent
427 F.3d 700 Oct 24, 2005 Tenth In Re Jeanne Lavonne Joelson, Debtor.stanley Cadwell, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Jeanne Lavonne Joelson, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 715 Oct 12, 2005 Tenth Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest; Interstate Indemnity Insurance Company, Plaintiffs—counter— Defendants—appellees, v. Charles D. Cline; Judith E. Davis, Defendants-counter-claimants-appellants
427 F.3d 717 Oct 14, 2005 Tenth William T. Browder, Plaintiff-appellant/cross-appellee, v. the City of Moab; Grand County; and the Grand County Solid Waste Management Service District # 1, Defendants-appellees/cross-appellants
427 F.3d 725 Oct 14, 2005 Tenth Mark J. Hunt, Appellant, v. Francheska Lamb, Also Known As Francheska Hunt, Appellee
427 F.3d 727 Oct 19, 2005 Tenth The Procter & Gamble Company, and the Procter & Gamble Distributing Company, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Randy L. Haugen, Freedom Tools Incorporated, Freedom Associates, Inc., Steven E. Brady, Stephen L. Bybee, Eagle Business Development, Inc., Ted Randall Walker, and Walker International Network, Defendants-appellees.microsoft Corporation, Exxonmobil Corporation, Nike, Inc., and Lawyers for Civil Justice, Amici Curiae
427 F.3d 745 Oct 21, 2005 Tenth Annabelle D. Mata, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Judy Saiz, Amy Hough, Donna Quintana, and Dana Weldon, Defendants-appellees
427 F.3d 767 Oct 21, 2005 Tenth Gerald Allen, Petitioner-appellant, v. Larry Reed, and John Suthers, the Attorney General of the State of Colorado, Respondents-appellees,colorado State Public Defender, Amicus Curiae
427 F.3d 775 Oct 25, 2005 Tenth Grace United Methodist Church, Plaintiff-appellant, v. City of Cheyenne; City of Cheyenne Board of Adjustment; Dorothy Wilson, City of Cheyenne Development Director; Cheyenne City Council, Defendant-appellees,mountview Park Homeowners' Association, Defendant-intervenor-appellee,united States of America, Plaintiff-intervenor-intervenor,the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, Amicus Curiae
427 F.3d 804 Oct 25, 2005 Tenth In Re: Commercial Financial Services, Inc., Debtor.houlihan Lokey Howard & Zukin Capital, Appellant, v. Unsecured Creditors' Liquidating Trust; Abs Liquidating Trustee; Commercial Financial Services, Inc; Cfs Liquidating Trustee; Cf/spc Ngu, Inc., United States Trustee, Appellees
427 F.3d 815 Oct 25, 2005 Tenth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Gerardo Corchado, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 821 Oct 26, 2005 Tenth Mactec, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant, v. Steven Gorelick, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 833 Oct 26, 2005 Tenth Luis Galvez Piñeda, Jr.; Maria Evelyn Roque Piñeda; Johanna Roque Piñeda; Robinson Roque Piñeda; Darwin Roque Piñeda; Amiel Roque Piñeda, Petitioners, v. Alberto R. Gonzales, United States Attorney General,* Respondent
427 F.3d 840 Oct 26, 2005 Tenth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Jerome M. Wenger, Also Known As Jerome Maxell Wenger, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 856 Oct 26, 2005 Tenth United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Huong Muessig; Sonny Lee Tran; Nga Tran, Also Known As Tanya Tran, Defendants-appellants
427 F.3d 867 Oct 04, 2005 Eleventh Hgi Associates, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant Cross-appellee, v. Wetmore Printing Company, a Texas Corporation, Defendant-appellee Cross-appellant
427 F.3d 881 Oct 05, 2005 Eleventh United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Kathy Mills Lee, Defendant-appellant.united States of America, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Joseph Michael Wyman, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 897 Oct 05, 2005 Eleventh James Callahan, Petitioner-appellee, v. Donal Campbell, Commissioner, Alabama Department of Corrections, Attorney General of Alabama, Respondents-appellants
427 F.3d 939 Oct 05, 2005 Eleventh Bryant Flury, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation, Defendant-appellant
427 F.3d 947 Oct 06, 2005 Eleventh Christine Kerr, Pat Green Smith, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. Mcdonald's Corporation, Defendant-appellee
427 F.3d 954 Oct 06, 2005 Eleventh Luis Fernando Chacon-botero, Petitioner, v. U.S. Attorney General, Respondent
427 F.3d 958 Oct 18, 2005 Federal Medimmune, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant, v. Genentech, Inc., Defendant-appellee, Andcity of Hope, Defendant-appellee, Andcelltech R & D, Ltd., Defendant-appellee